The Lincoln Wheat Penny Valued at $49,000 Still in Circulation

Let’s start with something that feels absolutely ridiculous—imagine rummaging through your loose change and pulling out a penny… that’s worth $49,000. Or even $950,000. Yeah, nearly a million bucks. For a penny.

Sounds like clickbait, right? But here’s the kicker: it’s real.

If you’ve got a Lincoln Wheat Penny from 1943 made of copper instead of steel, congratulations—you’ve hit the coin-collector lottery. These ultra-rare cents are not just old, they’re historic mistakes. And coin nerds (ahem, numismatists) will pay handsomely for them.

What’s So Special About a Lincoln Wheat Penny

Okay, quick flashback to elementary school history class.

The Lincoln Wheat Penny hit circulation in 1909, marking the 100th birthday of Honest Abe. On the front: Lincoln’s stoic mug. On the back: two wheat stalks curved like parentheses—simple, elegant, nostalgic.

These pennies stuck around until 1958, when the reverse design changed to the Lincoln Memorial. But within that nearly 50-year run, a few oddballs were accidentally minted—and those are the ones worth serious money.

The $49,000 Copper Mistake of 1943

Here’s where the plot thickens.

During World War II, copper was considered essential for military gear—bullets, wiring, all that jazz. So in 1943, the U.S. Mint started making pennies out of steel coated in zinc. They had a silver-ish appearance and were kind of weird-looking, honestly.

But somewhere in the chaos of wartime production, a few copper coin blanks got left behind in the minting machines. Boom—several 1943 pennies were struck on copper instead of steel. And just like that, the rarest American pennies were born.

How rare are we talking? Fewer than 20 are confirmed to exist. Which makes their value shoot through the roof.

Steel or Copper? How to Spot the Difference

Let’s make this easy:

Coin Year	Material	Color	Common or Rare?	Potential Value
1943	Steel (zinc-coated)	Silvery-gray	Super common	5¢ to $2
1943	Copper	Brown/reddish	Extremely rare (mistake)	$49,000–$950,000+
1944	Copper (normal)	Brown/reddish	Common-ish	$0.10 to $5

If your 1943 penny looks silvery, it’s almost certainly steel—worth pocket change, literally.

But if it’s brownish like most other copper coins? Don’t go spending it at the vending machine. You might be holding a fortune.

Quick test: try a magnet. Steel pennies stick. Copper ones won’t. (Still doesn’t confirm authenticity, but it’s a good first check.)

Wait… One Sold for How Much?

You ready for this?

In 2010, a 1943-D Bronze (copper) Lincoln cent sold for $1.7 million in a private transaction. That’s not a typo.

Another copper 1943 penny sold at auction for nearly $950,000 in 2019.

Most don’t go that high, of course. But even a “lesser” example in good condition might fetch $49,000–$250,000 depending on mint mark and quality. That’s a used Tesla Model X in your coin jar.

Could One Be in Circulation?

In theory? Yeah.

In reality? You’ve got better odds of being hit by lightning twice while winning the lottery and being offered a modeling contract in Walmart on the same day.

Still—people do weird things. Coins get lost. Grandpa’s stash ends up in a kid’s piggy bank. One guy bought a sandwich and accidentally paid with a $100,000 penny. It happens.

So check your change. Just in case.

Got One? Don’t Do This…

Whatever you do, don’t clean it. Not even a little. Coin collectors are purists. Scrubbing or polishing a rare coin can knock thousands (yes, thousands) off its value.

Instead, here’s what you do:

1. Don’t panic.
2. Handle it gently (use gloves if possible).
3. Get it appraised by a legit coin expert.
4. Consider sending it to a top grading service like PCGS or NGC.

That’ll get you an official authentication and condition rating—vital for resale.

Real Talk: Is It Worth Digging Through Pennies?

Look, you’re not likely to find one. But it’s possible—and that’s enough to turn ordinary folks into amateur treasure hunters.

If nothing else, it makes going through your coin jar a lot more exciting. Like buying a lottery ticket, but with slightly better odds and no losing your shirt.

Plus, it’s kind of poetic that something so small and forgotten—just a penny—could change someone’s life.

FAQs